
Don't we all know this in our hearts?
When Jon Stewart made
his legendary appearance on Crossfire back in 2004, the two hosts repeatedly asked him why he didn't ask hard-hitting questions of political figures like John Kerry. Stewart responded, as he has many times before and since, that
The Daily Show is a comedy program and is not held to any standard of fairness or journalistic integrity. He made the hilarious comparison: "This is CNN! The show after me is puppets making prank phone calls!"
Stewart has kept this defense going for a long time. It has become standard procedure for
The Daily Show to satirize, criticize, and ridicule ruthlessly and hilariously and then duck behind the "it's entertainment!" shield without apology. A month ago CNBC host
Jim Cramer appeared on the show, and Stewart raked him over the coals for his past shady business practices and sensationalist "get rich quick" financial advice. At the end of what was one of the most hard-hitting, honest interviews I've ever watched, Stewart asked Kramer if "maybe we could remove the financial expert and the 'in Kramer we trust' and start getting back to the fundamentals on the reporting as well, and I could go back to making fart noises and funny faces."
"BACK" to humor. Even Stewart himself realizes
The Daily Show has become much more than a comedy program. In the last year Stewart has talked a heck of a lot more and joked a lot less in his interviews (see
this "interview" with Peggy Noonan, in which Peggy listens to Jon talk about the presidential race). A few days ago, journalist
Cliff May came on the program and had a more open, honest, heated debate with Stewart over the torture issue than any of the major networks have aired - May said so himself. There was scarcely a joke to be found.
It might sound like I'm reprimanding the show, but I'm not.
The Daily Show is my favorite television program. I absolutely love it. But the show and its viewers need to come to grips with the fact that Jon Stewart is one of the greatest newsmen of our time. I think he deserves comparison to Bob Scheiffer, Tim Russert, or Edward R. Murrow.
The New York Times thinks he is
the most trusted man in America, and Counterpunch thinks
he has saved us all. As such, the excuse or charge that
The Daily Show is not journalism is lacking.
Of course, outside of the interview segment of the program which features political figures such as past presidents, the U.K. prime minister, cabinet members, and last week the French finance minister, the show is still mostly satirical comedy. Though the non-interview segments do provoke needed discussion about issues and events, I wouldn't suggest that someone use the show as their primary source of finding out what's happening in the world. My guess is the topics presented on the show, which are discussed sometimes obscenely and always with foul language, are still chosen primarily for their ability to get laughs. This doesn't matter however, because nobody is doing it.
A Pew Research study showed that
Daily Show and
Colbert Report viewers are more informed than those who watch Fox News and CNN. Turns out satirical news comedy draws people who already know the news.
Besides, in a world where technology is consuming traditional forms of journalism by the hour and 24-hour news networks are running any piece of fear, controversy, or sensationalism they can get their hands on to sell commercials - maybe we need to redefine what news really is anyway.
So if you're a Daily Show viewer, don't listen to the haters who say it's not journalism. And if you're Jon Stewart, stop hiding and be yourself man! We're behind you.